The Ultimate Source for your Ph.D. in Pigskin

Home

Draft

Rankings

Picks

Audio/Video

Ask the Doc

Archive

2008 Week Seventeen Power Rankings


It's incredibly difficult to arrange the power rankings after the last week of the season, because many of the teams that are locked into a playoff position don't play their best players, or do so sparingly. So, you will see that many teams retained their rankings despite a win or loss last week. For instance, the Giants losing to the Vikings with David "Mr. Mittens" Carr at the helm doesn't sway me to believe that there's a better team out there.

 

1   New York Giants (12-4) They impressed me by barely losing to a motivated Vikings team while playing mostly backups for a half.
2   Indianapolis (12-4) Tony Dungy and Peyton Manning have this team peaking at just the right time.
3   Tennessee (13-3) They were really pushed around by an undermanned Colts defense. For their sake, I hope they get well soon for when they play a physical Ravens' team.
4   Pittsburgh (12-4) Everyone's blaming Mike Tomlin for playing Ben Roethlisberger. Personally, I think coaches should play their regulars if they have a bye week.
5   Carolina (12-4) Allowing the Saints to get back in that game probably didn't make John Fox very happy.
6   Baltimore (11-5) Ed Reed just made my Defensive Player of the Year vote that much more interesting.
7   New England (11-5) They didn't make the playoffs, but at least the Patriots know they're set at the quarterback position even if Tom Brady can't come back in 2009.
8   Atlanta (11-5) I can't remember a better rookie year for a quarterback than the one Matt Ryan just finished.
9   Philadelphia (9-6-1) Let's see if Eagles' fans still feel the same way about Andy Reid and Donovan McNabb. No, I didn;t think so, either.
10   Miami (11-5) They weren't pretty, but you have to credit Bill Parcells and Tony Sporano for the turnaround they orchestrated.
11   San Diego (8-8) It took 17 weeks, but they finally looked like the Chargers I picked to win the Super Bowl.
12   Dallas (9-7) What a waste of a good team. I can't believe that Jerry Jones is going to stick with Wade Phillips.
13

  Minnesota (10-6) This team will not survive next week's matchup against the opportunistic Eagles unless Adrian Peterson solves his fumbling problem.
14   Tampa Bay (9-7) You can say what you want about the Monte Kiffin distraction, but their collapse was caused by their aging defense tiring as the season wore on.
15   New York Jets (9-7) I never thought I'd say this: Brett, please do us all a favor and retire.
16   Houston (8-8) Mark my words, this team will be in the playoffs next year.
17   Arizona (9-7) The only way they can beat the Falcons is if Matt Ryan finally starts playing like a rookie - and I just don't see that happening.
18   Denver (8-8) I'll be interested to see if Mike Shanahan is replaced by a defensive-minded coach.
19   Chicago (9-7) Kyle Orton played well, and probably wasn't the biggest problem, but the Bears have to get a playmaking quarterback this offseason.
20   Washington (8-8) Jason Campbell took one step forward and two steps back this season. I'm beginning to wonder if he's the answer in Washington.
21   New Orleans (8-8) The good news is that they finished in last place in the NFC South. Of course, that means they have a really good chance of winning it next year.
22   San Francisco (7-9) What a great turnaround. If Mike Singletary gets an offensive coordinator that he believes in next year, this team could very well win their division.
23   Green Bay (6-10) If nothing else, the Packers found out that Aaron Rodgers is the real deal. Now about that defense....
24   Oakland (5-11) Someone needs to drag JaMarcus Russell into the facility every day this offseason, because they will only go as far as he can take them.
25   Buffalo (7-9) I was very happy to see Dick Jauron keep his job. Simply put, he wasn't the problem - it was a combination of bad luck and timely injuries.
26   Jacksonville (5-11) They are by far my most disappointing team this season. I just can't see the reason for a 5-11 season.
27   Cincinnati (4-11-1) It looks like Cedric Benson may have finally found a home - 282 yards and a 4.5 yards per carry average in the last two games will do that for you.
28   Seattle (4-12) This may sound goofy, but they actually looked better with Seneca Wallace at quarterback this year. Sorry Matt, but it's time to look for another in the draft.
29   Kansas City (2-14) Let Larry Johnson go, Chiefs' fans. Trust me, he's no longer worth it.
30   Cleveland (4-12) Romeo Crennel and Phil Savage had to go - it's obvious that the players just didn;t believe in either of them anymore..
31   St. Louis (2-14) Whoever the coach is next year, he has to believe in two things: get Steven Jackson the ball and stop someone...anyone!
32   Detroit (0-16) I've never felt more sorry for any athlete than I have for all of the Detroit Lions. Every one of them looked like they were about to cry over the past few weeks.

Make sure to catch Jimmy Neil every Friday from 12:30 to 2:00 PM, Saturday from 2:00 to 4:00 PM, and Sunday at 4:30, only on 1560 AM or www.1560thegame.com